WhiteCoat Rants

Random thoughts about US Healthcare

  • Archives

  • Spam Blocked

  • Meta

  • -----------------

    Medical Transcription Services
    Serving US physicians and hospitals since 1998. Dictate toll-free or via digital recorder. Fully secure and HIPAA compliant. Guaranteed 24 hour turnaround - faster turnaround time available. Interface with all major EMR systems.

Glenn Beck Blasts Hospital That Treated Him - UPDATED

Posted by WhiteCoat on January 6, 2008

I found a seven minute video clip that Glenn Beck made after getting home from surgery on Friday.

He stated that his surgery went “horribly awry” and that he “almost” died. He praised the physicians and nurses as being “incredible,” but bashed the hospital as being “phenomenally bad.” He has stories to “melt the brain” and hopes that his stories “melt the brain of the CEO.” Because this hospital treats the president of GE, and because Glenn Beck alleges that he was nearly killed, he now asserts that he knows how all the average “schlubbs” are treated in the US healthcare system. At one point, he stated that some things that happened to him “could have come out of the movie ‘Saw.’”

He learned the meaning of compassion and thinks that he can now define it. He believes that most people don’t understand compassion, but now he has some real examples of compassion, what it means, and how to apply it.

Stated that he was in a drug-induced state that drove him to the point of being “full-fledged suicidal” in which he would have “blown his brains out” with a handgun. Within 3 days, he said that he went from a feeling of great success to feeling that there was “absolutely no reason to live.”

I think Glenn Beck has his moments. Not a huge fan, but like hearing what he has to say. He overdramatizes some things at times, but I’m guilty of that myself. He also thinks outside the box more than most people and I like that a lot about him. He has the insight to see the big picture. I just hope that he’s not going to whine because he wasn’t treated like as much of a VIP as the president of GE.

His video kept saying that he “can’t wait to tell us about it.” Supposedly more is coming out in his TV and radio broadcasts tomorrow.

I can’t wait to hear about it.

Hat tip to Mediabistro.com and its TVNewser service.

UPDATE JANUARY 10, 2008
Due to working long hours, I’m a little late to the public flogging on this subject, but I had to throw in my two cents. I enjoyed reading the comments made by Kevin, MD and his readers. One post stated that Glenn’s surgery was for … hemorrhoids.

After reading Glenn’s post about the incident, I was a little disappointed. No, I was very disappointed. To me, this came across as a media stunt. He’s not someone who needs that big of a rating’s boost. The people who watched his show to hear more about “things from the movie ‘Saw’” were most likely disappointed and my guess is that he lost more in negative press than he gained in viewership.

His first theme seemed to be pain control. Hemorrhoids are painful, sure. If your “amazing” doctors didn’t prep you by telling you that this is a very painful surgery, then they aren’t quite as amazing as you think. So the pain is there. First question I have is why is someone on morphine, fentanyl, and Percocet for pain control after hemorrhoid surgery? What does being “stabilized” in pain after surgery mean? Being pain-free? I don’t think so. And if you have the unrealistic expectation of being pain-free every minute after surgery, you are setting yourself up for an overdose. If you’re taking several narcotics plus another pain medication that “starts with an ‘N’” then of course you’re going to be “screwed up.” This wasn’t the hospital’s fault, this was the fault of the physician (or physicians) who prescribed you all of these medications.

Glenn digresses for a second to tell everyone how after his story hit the Drudge Report, the hospital president called Glenn “all freaked out.” Glenn writes that the hospital president “doesn’t get it” whatever “it” is. Let’s put this in perspective. If the head of CNN read on the Drudge Report that Glenn Beck had performed some heinous act and that Martha Stewart was going to take it public, don’t you think the head of CNN would call Martha Stewart “all freaked out” to find out what the problem was? Did you ever think of speaking to a hospital administrator before dropping this bomb on them? Doubt it. Glenn, you’ve been given a tremendous gift that Teddy Roosevelt called the “bully pulpit” and you’ve misused it. You’ve advanced your own agenda like Ellen DeGeneres advanced some agenda against a dog shelter. The hospital president had a right to be “freaked out” and I’ll tell you why, but, as you put it in your rambling website post, you have to “wait for the end of the story” (and by the way, you never did tell anyone what “it” was or why the hospital president “didn’t get it”)

Glenn states that his doctors “called ahead” to make sure that the emergency department was waiting for him when he arrived. If his doctors really did that, they were idiots. Things don’t work that way in an emergency department. It’s not a restaurant.

“Sorry ma’am, I know you’re having acute myocardial ischemia, but this room is reserved for Glenn Beck - you know, THE Glenn Beck. Yeah, him. You’ll just have to wait until the staff is all done with him.” Not happening.

You don’t get appointments in the ED. You get seen by severity of illness. If someone is shot in the chest or having a stroke, you better believe that someone with hemorrhoid pain and a full bladder is going to sit in the waiting room. Imagine the inverse: “Glenn Beck dies of heart attack while doctors insert Foley catheter into poor little old lady who couldn’t pee.”

If the surgeons were really “the best team of doctors you could imagine,” they would have met you at the hospital or met you at their office. Instead, they dump you on the ED. Great guys.

The ED staff was less than compassionate with you. Granted. For someone who isn’t exactly known for his compassion, I was surprised at how personally you took the actions of the medical staff. I’m not condoning what they did, but it would be nice to have the staff’s side of the story. By now they have probably been fired to quell the storm you have created.

Then you sat in the ER with your bladder “extended” for two hours. Here’s the next question I have: Why did your “amazing” doctors send you home with a distended bladder? You didn’t make that whole 1500 cc of urine in 2-4 hours. If your doctors were really so great, they should have known that one of the side effects of narcotics is urinary retention. Wonder what the side effects of four different narcotics would be (besides respiratory depression). Perhaps more urinary retention? Didn’t they make you urinate before you left? There are a lot of things I am questioning right about now and not many of them have to do with the hospital.

Then you get to the floor and what do your doctors prescribe you? More narcotics. More respiratory depression. More urinary retention. I’m not sure why it took you five days to get off the pain medication, but nothing you said seemed like anything from the movie “Saw.”

So, Glenn, I’m disappointed for a lot of reasons. I thought you had more insight than you apparently do. Perhaps you and your wife weren’t treated with common decency when you were in need. That needs to be addressed with the administration of the hospital, not with the national media.
Then you failed to address the big picture. Why is this happening to you and the average “schlubb” as you put it? You didn’t address how the system is crumbling before our eyes. More ED visits, less EDs, no reimbursement, whacked out malpractice atmosphere, disjointed care, patient dumping, long waits for care. The list goes on and on. Why don’t you talk to the American College of Emergency Physicians about this?
You had the opportunity to bring these issues to the forefront. Instead you wrote some rambling mishmash of self-pity and suicidal ideations because you couldn’t cope with the pain of hemorrhoid surgery. You did nothing to change the situation, although I’m sure some people were fired because they weren’t nice to THE Glenn Beck. Now I see where your comments about the president of GE come in.

Rather than turn your story into a cogent discussion of how to improve the healthcare system, you turned your story into the latest YouTube craze and a ratings stunt. Congratulations.

At least CNN still has Robin Meade.

14 Responses to “Glenn Beck Blasts Hospital That Treated Him - UPDATED”

  1. SeaSpray Says:

    Tag…your it WhiteCoat! Hope you don’t mind and hope you come out to play if you can. :)

  2. SeaSpray Says:

    Shoot…I think I am supposed to tell you to check out the rules in my blog. :)

  3. TK Says:

    What the heck? Doesn’t seem to make a lot of sense to me.

  4. tagaAmerica.com » Glenn Beck Blasts Hospital That Treated Him « WhiteCoat Rants Says:

    [...] Glenn Beck Blasts Hospital That Treated Him « WhiteCoat Rants [...]

  5. sparkle333 Says:

    Hi: I just watched the tape. I love Glenn Beck, and I was just wondering what happened? What kind of surgery was it? I will definitely be watching, as I feel a local hospital killed my dad after triple bypass surgery. I hope he’s going to be okay!

  6. thesaj Says:

    Having experienced first hand the crap that the medical field can dish out without caring. I understand his criticism.

    I also understand his praise of the nurse who did come to aide, and what a different that makes.

    I ounce found myself in a hospital with a 105 degree temperature. Was put on an IV, given antibiotics and $20 worth of Tylenol. And given a bunch of blood test.

    Finally, a doctor comes in to inform me with a smile on her face that the diagnosis looks like I have Hepatitus C. I was shocked…”how” i asked?

    She replies with a smug expression. “Well, have you been sleeping around or using drugs.”

    I replied “No, never done either…” (at the time I was a 20 yr old virgin and I have never used narcotics) to which I she replied “Well, you must have been doing something.”

    Later tests showed that I did not have Hep-C. What I had was a third friggin kidney.

    But yeah…bad bedside manner, lack of courtesy, rudeness…sadly, it can be way too common in the medical field. All that aside, there are some stellar doctors and nurses. In fact, most are…and more would be if they weren’t working four 14 hour shifts.

  7. Ann Says:

    It takes a little bit of humility to teach compassion. Maybe next time he wants to bash someone he’ll remember his experience. Treat how you want to be treated.

  8. Marsha Says:

    I have read many posts from nurses about Glen Becks experience and you all sound pretty heartless. Why don’t go do a job that you don’t hate. What a bunch of bitter people. Mr Beck deserved to be treated with kindness. Do you remember that word? or do they wipe the ability to show kindness out of you in nursing school. RNs are some of the most arrogant and mean individuals I come across. How they treat people should be monitored at the hospitals. I can’t believe how you all can be so cold!

    A failure to treat someone with kindness does not equate to “something straight out of the movie ‘Saw’” and has little bearing on whether someone received appropriate medical care. Sure, in an ideal world, everyone would be happy and have kindness oozing from every orifice in their body. Does that mean that Glenn Beck next blasts WalMart when the overworked checkout lady doesn’t smile at him and fails to say “Have a nice day”?
    P.S. I love my job. :-)

  9. sparkle333 Says:

    Well I love Glenn Beck, but I must say that I was REALLY disappointed in this whole scenario. I even got up to watch him and his wife on a morning show,hoping he would elaborate, and he still didn’t say anything! My dad died because of hospital neglect after a triple bypass, and I just feel that so many people have been through so much worse than what glenn experienced.(Though they could have killed him with that much medication.) There are problems-huge problems-with health care, and I was hoping that Glenn Beck would have a forum to discuss this, and give it more attention. But for someone who makes a living by communicating (and does a great job of it) his telling of this story was disjointed and difficult to follow. I agree that most of the problems that he noted were caused by his “amazing” doctors! They are the ones who had him on enough meds to kill him!

  10. Memama Says:

    I discovered 1st hand how terrible the care is on a “critical care” floor after heart stent surgery. My doctor arrived one and a half hours late. I complained of a infiltrated I.V. (my armed swelled up for 2 days)this was of course dismissed, I had no pain control. my nitro drip bottle was on full blast causing me to vomit and migraine. The LPN’s were a disinterested group of unresponsive caregivers. I had no doctor come to see me, I was not hydrated or fed properly. My t.v. control was broken and I begged people to turn it off, which did not happen. I cannot describe the feeling of being in extreme pain, unable to get help and have disinterested caregivers. I got to leave after 2 days. I went home dirty, dehydrated, and wondering if this is “critical care” then God help the other people on the regular floors. I was in a chaotic,extremely noisy, neglectful, atmosphere that was anything but healing after a heart procedure. p.s. I used to be a Candy Stripe volunteer in high School at another Hospital and also worked as a Dental Assistant. I know how to care for people in pain and distress, its called “doing your job”.

    I’m sorry for your bad experience.
    But I encourage you to look at your situation from the caregiver’s point of view. You know how to care for people in pain in distress, but could you care for 12 people in pain and distress? Twelve people who need medications at varying times, who need IVs, who need meals, who need the TV turned off, who have multiple family members calling about their progress, who need help to the bathroom, who need transport to physical therapy and radiology and cardiology, etc. The list goes on. Oops … charting! Let’s not forget all the charting that nurses have to do. Oh, and do the nurses get time to eat and urinate sometime during their shift?
    I don’t know what happened in your case. Consider the possibility that perhaps your caregivers weren’t “disinterested” but were instead “overwhelmed.” It doesn’t justify what happened to you, but maybe it will give you a little insight into the cause of such problems.
    Take a look at ER Nursey’s blog sometime.

  11. Bergs43 Says:

    I won’t bore anyone with my nightmarish hospital experience; I just want to share what I’ve learned. If you must be hospitalized, make sure you secure (ahead of time, like NOW) a family member or friend willing to be your “patient advocate”. Pick this person carefully, as they will need to visit you everyday and have the backbone to DEMAND you receive basic care. When you are immobile and in terrible pain, you just can’t do this yourself. You are at their mercy and they are merciless.


    I disagree that “they are merciless.” People don’t get into this line of work to be merciless. See my response to the post above.
    That being said, having a “patient advocate” is a good idea. Not only can that person help you to get the care you need, but that person can also witness the causes of some delays.

  12. thatdanachick Says:

    I’ve read a few of your blog entries and I’m hooked.

    Through an interesting set of circumstances, I’ve spent the past three years working in a few different capacities in the ER. Even the most mundane day at work produces far more fodder for my various and sundry writing projects than anything else I could have imagined.

    I’m looking forward to reading more, and I’ll be linking to you in my blogroll.

    Cheers!

  13. Martha Says:

    “I’m sorry for your bad experience
    But I encourage you to look at your situation from the caregiver’s point of view….etc and so forth..blah blah blah..”

    No, you’re not, “sorry,” except for yourselves. And it’s terminal. If nurses and other caregivers in hospitals cannot help but take out their frustration and unhappiness on the patients, they need to find another career, because their own negative attitudes only make them appear to be heartless, vindictive and mean. Period.

    I tend not to have a negative attitude until I have to listen to the entitlement crowd. It’s amusing how whiny people like you get all up in arms because health care professionals treat everyone like drug seekers, then, in the next breath you criticize all health care professionals for being mean to you.
    It’s bad when health care workers allegedly paint the patients with a broad brush, but it’s OK when whiny patients who think they’re entitled to a room with a TV, a warm blanket, and a mint on their pillow paint all health care workers as “heartless, vindictive, and mean.” Get over yourself.
    If you don’t like the way that organized medicine treats you, next time you are sick, click here, follow the directions, and save yourself, the doctors, and the nurses all a bunch of aggravation.

  14. Martha Says:

    And one more thing: Compassion goes a long way. Perhaps many nurses have forgotten that. I think they have. If you cannot alleviate someone’s pain because you’re waiting to hear frome the doc or whomever, at least be civil and not ignore your patient. Most of us, despite your preconceived notions, are not trying to be a pain in your ass, a fact that does not seem to stop many nurses from acting like we are.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>