WhiteCoat Rants

Random thoughts about US Healthcare

  • Archives

  • Spam Blocked

  • Meta

  • ----------

    CHARITY OF THE MONTH
    AnySoldier.com
    Don't forget our troops!

    Donate $50 or more to the charity of the month and get a text ad in this sidebar for 30 days.

At The Radiologist’s Mercy

Posted by WhiteCoat on January 7, 2008

This post may seem like I have it in for radiologists. I don’t. The radiologists at our hospital are all top-notch. Just blowing off some steam and showing how we can sometimes be put at the mercy of another doctor’s statements. What a night.

An elderly patient comes in after falling in the bathroom and hitting her head and face on the bathtub. She has a nice shiner on her left eye and hasn’t been acting quite right since it happened according to the family members.

We subject her to various forms of ionizing radiation - probably the equivalent of being at “ground zero” - and find that her neck is OK and that she has no bleeding or other injury inside of her brain. After all of the lab tests are back, we still can’t really figure out why she her mental status is not quite right, so we admit her for observation. I make all the calls to the admitting physician, the consultant, the floor, write admitting orders, explain everything to the family, and make sure the patient is comfortable. Then the fun begins.

About a half hour after the patient goes to the floor, we get a fax from the teleradiologist. The radiologist who read the initial scan made a mistake. The patient actually has a subdural hematoma. Great. There’s no neurosurgeon at our hospital, its the middle of the night, and I’m the only physician in the hospital. We have to transfer this patient to another hospital for a neurosurgery evaluation - right after she’d been admitted. We call the nurses upstairs to stop admitting the patient and get her ready for transfer. I call the admitting doc and let him know what’s going on. I call the family to try to smooth things over as to why we’re suddenly transferring their mom after they had all just gone home. I fill out all the paperwork for transfer (yes, I know that the admitting doc could have done this, but I chose to spend 10 minutes doing it myself rather than making him get out of bed, evaluate a patient he’d never seen, write an admitting note, then fill out the transfer forms himself). No ambulances were available for transfer, so the receiving hospital sends one of their ambulances and a crew to come get the patient. Fortunately, we have great nursing supervisors that helped organize a lot of the transfer process.

I’m trying to catch up on the patients in the ED when we get another fax about an hour later. This fax says that the teleradiologist’s reading was incorrect and that the “subdural hematoma” was just a motion artifact. There really isn’t any bleeding.

You have to be f’ing kidding me.

Call the ambulance dispatch and have the ambulance crew turn around to go home. “I’m sorry they’re 3/4 of the way here. What am I supposed to do?”
Call the family and tell them not to go to the other hospital - mom’s staying here. “Well, there was another mistake in the reading on her CT scan. No, ma’am, I was not the one who read it. I don’t appreciate being called an idiot - I’m trying to help. I’m very sorry for the confusion. I’ll put you through to the administrator on call. Hold on.”
Tell the floor they don’t have that extra bed they thought they had. “I’m sorry you just tore up all the admission papers and have to re-write everything. She’s staying here.”
Even I wasn’t cruel enough to wake the admitting doc up again.

After all this, I was surprised that I didn’t have a subdural from banging my head on the wall.

17 Responses to “At The Radiologist’s Mercy”

  1. TK Says:

    OMG what a disaster! Was that “Nighthawks” by any chance? We use them and usually they are good but occasionally they miss stuff - although I have never had one recind a revision! I can imagine the nightmare trying to explain to the family. I bet they write a letter complaining to the hospital (although hopefully they will praise your efforts personally).

  2. scalpel Says:

    It might have been better to go ahead and transfer the patient anyway. Just in case, right?

  3. feminizedwesternmale Says:

    Did you call the radiologist, and give him some tough love. He sure needed it.

  4. Surfie Says:

    Where does your teleradiologist reside? I betting another country. Outsourcing at its finest (again).

  5. shadowfax Says:

    Why was the scan read three times? If your own rad had looked at it initially, and correctly read it as negative, why did it go to telerad at all?

    I love digital radiology b/c I get the images on line as soon as the radiologist does. This is why I over-read all my own films. If I get a reading I didn’t expect, then I’m on the phone with the rad before getting led down the garden path. Sure, more often they’re explaining to me that the “appendicitis” I thought I saw is actually a ureter, but hey…

  6. honestpoet Says:

    What a hassle! At least it wasn’t a missed tumor, like what happened with my best friend, who’s now struggling with stage 4B cervical.

    I’m glad to find your blog. I’m married to a psychiatrist, so I get a very different perspective (believe me, he often has plenty to rant about himself). Funny thing, though, is he started in radiology, and finished all but the last six months of that residency before deciding he wanted to actually see patients.

  7. SeaSpray Says:

    Oh-h-h WhiteCoat! What-a-night!

    Do the radiologists like YOU??? ;)

    I am easy going but I think after that my faith in the staff wouldn’t be real strong at that point. Lay people would understandably wonder if you all know what you are doing. Unfortunately for you…you were their contact person.

    I would also be wanting to talk to radiology..no matter how stellar they are. :)

  8. X-Ray Geek Says:

    You mean he didn’t finish off his report with clinical correlation recommended???? Or is symptoms persist, get a (insert favorite modality here)? Being the one that works under the rad, there are many days where I want to shake the living heck out of them and tell them to make up their freakin mind!!!

    See the next post :-)

  9. SeaSpray Says:

    BTW…if the pt’s mental status was off a bit…do you think she was anymore confused? Or did all this happen around her and she stayed in her room the entire time oblivious to it all.

    This is also a perfect example of all the “behind the scenes” WORK hospital staff does on behalf of their pts and ties them up from helping others.

  10. Nurse K Says:

    Let’s smile, hold hands, and look on the bright side—the American taxpayers (and the patient) were saved the expense of a costly ambulance transfer.

    Poor little granny sounds like she had—a concussion.

  11. Dx:Ddx Says:

    Ain’t it wonderful to be a doctor?
    To care for patients?
    God I’d hate to spend my life looking
    Looking at Fourier transformations of
    Radiated or magnetized
    Patients when I could be
    Caring for them.

    Too bad they are more
    Valued
    than me.

  12. tagaAmerica.com » At The Radiologist’s Mercy « WhiteCoat Rants Says:

    [...] At The Radiologist’s Mercy « WhiteCoat Rants [...]

  13. T Ellis Says:

    Sounds like she needed a neuro consult anyway, with or without a positive scan.

  14. TK Says:

    I just had a similar case last night. I had JUST discharged a woman who looked like she had a negative (but traumatic) LP and a reportedly normal MRI/MRA when our neuroradiologist called to tell me the guy that read it initially had missed a subtle SAH!! He did say it could have been caused by the tap (introducing a small amt of blood into the canal) but when I called the patient back, she said she felt fine and didn’t want to come back unless she got much worse. I was like “shit, shit, shit, shit!” Fingers are crossed I don’t get a letter signed by someone…Esq!

  15. JaneMarieMD Says:

    Shadowfax is right-it’s a good idea to look at the actual films whenever you can. Of course it isn’t realistic to look at all films, but I like to look at the ‘positive’ ones so I can learn some radiology. I have seen CTs with subdurals before, and our radiologists often put arrows on CTs to help us (poorly-paid) clinicians (doin’ the direct patient care!!) find the abnormality.

    Let’s face it–uncertainty is everywhere!! Jerome Groopman stirred me to some momentary sympathy for radiologists with the chapter in his book about their errors; Eric Cassell has written the most eloquently about the seductive nature of technology–that it will remove all doubt–yet doubt and uncertainty remain.

    Sigh …

    Thanks for sharing the story!

  16. X-ray Rocks Says:

    Stories like this make a person nostalgic
    for the LOCAL on call Rad. of yesteryear.
    Not so nostalgic about waking that Rad. up
    in the middle of the night!

  17. dr dave 26 Says:

    My sympathies to you on the mess you dealt with. Agree with T Ellis probably just go through with the transfer and get 2nd read by Neurosurg and eval of the AMS. They always repeat the studies at the referral center also.I was recruited to work in an ER and later found didn’t have after hours reading period. The current docs were so proud of the fact that they had been “taught” by the radiologist to read their own CT scans at night. Hmm, I wonder why he was so kind to teach them this new skill? Sleep all night and still bill for am overreads-nice gig if you can get it. I pointed out to them that they did not want to be on the stand someday when the plaintiff attorney aks, “And Dr. ER doc where did you do your radiology training, get your board certification, etc”. Time to stroke a check… I too learned quickly to read many CTs and got pretty good at it. But as Med Director I was alarmed and pushed admin to get telerad (big capital outlay and lost revenue for hospital radiologist losing am overreads). Now we use telerad, but I still look at the scans right away. Can often pick up things for immediate dispo and not have to wait on telerad reading.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>