Restraint
Posted by WhiteCoat on April 2, 2008
Lately it seems like these weird things only happen to me.
Paramedics brought in this pleasant young woman named Deborah Peel who had been using crack cocaine at home just prior to her arrival. She then got into an argument with her husband, called 911, and hung up. Since 911 hangups automatically result in a visit by the local police, Ms. Peel was both surprised and upset when the local sheriff knocked at her door. She then ran into the kitchen, took a handful of Effexor, chewed up the pills, swallowed most of them, and spit the rest at the officer who was chasing after her.
So not only did Ms. Peel arrive by ambulance, she also sported a nice set of matching metal bracelets and a was accompanied by a police escort. All the way to the hospital she kept telling the paramedics that if she couldn’t go home, she would kill herself.
She was screaming obscenities when she arrived. She got into the room and didn’t want to be there. Eventually the nurses were able to calm her down to the point where she would allow blood draws and an IV insertion. She was relatively calm when I went into the room, but she was still upset about being in the hospital.
She wouldn’t cooperate that much with the history. She did state that she was still “suicidal.” I told her that we would get her help, but that we had to make sure that she was medically stable before seeing the psychiatrist. Because the pills she took have a potentially fatal side effect, I told her that we would have to pump her stomach to get the pills out and to administer charcoal.
Deborah Peel went nuts.
She pulled on the tubing to the blood pressure cuff and tried to knock over the monitor. The security guard ran into the room. She ripped off all of her EKG leads. She began screaming and swearing at me. Then she went to pull out her IV. I grabbed her hand before she was able to do so. Then something happened to me that has never happened to me in my career … I got punched.
Using her free hand, Deborah Peel punched me in the chest. I saw it coming at the last second, so I leaned back and she didn’t get me that hard, but she still got me. Then she took another swing at my face. I leaned my head back and she missed.
I have trained a lot in different martial arts. I still had a grip on the arm that she was going to use to pull out her IV, so I twisted her wrist into a joint lock and told her to stop. She yelled “you want to fight ME?” and then took another swing at my face, this time catching the corner of my eye with her finger.
At that time, my mind went into a time warp.
If I let her go, then either she goes after the security guard or she falls off the bed. In either case, someone could get hurt. Don’t let her go.
First, my mind flashed to my martial arts training. Her open targets were both eyes which I could gouge very easily, her nose which I could hit very forcefully with my forearm/elbow, and her throat which I could hit with the heel of my hand or my forearm.
Then my mind flashed to what consequences would occur if I chose to strike the patient. Would it be considered self defense? Could she press charges against me? What if I seriously injured her? Why should a physician even be in a situation where striking a patient would be a consideration?
By then, the instinct to strike back had passed. I was able to keep control of one hand while the security guard got control of her other hand. The patient traded in her metal bracelets for some leather ones - along with matching ankle bracelets.
Then the patient’s husband came into the room. His questions bothered me as much as the patient’s actions:
“What did you expect her to do if you were trying to jam a tube down her nose?”
“Well, sir, she attacked me before we even tried to do that.”
“You know she has issues…”
“Sorry, no, I did not know that, and even if I did know that, people with ‘issues’ don’t have the right to do whatever they want to other people.”
“Well at the other hospitals she has been at, if someone is suicidal, they restrain them immediately. If you had of just restrained her when she came in, this wouldn’t have happened.”
“We can’t just restrain someone that is not an imminent threat to themselves or others.”
“She didn’t even hurt you … did she?”
“Are you suggesting that it is OK to punch people as long as you don’t ‘hurt’ them?”
“Well, no. She’s a psych patient anyway. She didn’t know what she was doing.”
That urge to hit someone was coming back. I’m forced to provide medical care to someone by virtue of a federal law, the patient hits me, and now her enabling husband is treating me like I’m the one at fault.
Can someone remind me why I enjoy my job so much?
The rest of the story is that I pressed assault and battery charges with the police.
When the call went out on the radio, a couple of ED employees who listen to police scanners called into the ED to find out what happened. In no time, it was all over the hospital that WhiteCoat got hit by some crazy lady named Deborah Peel.
According to the police, Ms. Peel has a history of previous arrests. Assaulting a health care worker is a felony in our state, so she’s reportedly going to be spending a couple of years in the GrayBar Hotel.
Last, but not least, I have caught more crap from people in the past 12 hours than I have caught in a long time.
“Hey - I heard some old lady kicked your ass!”
“Oooh, let me know which martial arts gym you go to. You all get some gooood training there.”
“I heard they’re hiring your son as security guard so that we have some real protection around here.”
Now I remember why I enjoy my job so much.
I fit right in.
Everyone’s a smart-ass.


April 2, 2008 at 5:13 pm
I think we need to start a pool…the one that says when your suit and ties from the ivory tower tell you to NOT press charges!!!
I say by 1201 on 4-3-08….oh wait that would be during their lunch break…ok by 1159 on 4-3-08!!!
Steve
We actually have a great administration and they have backed other staff members who have pressed charges against patients in the past. Don’t think it will happen, but we’ll see.
April 2, 2008 at 6:34 pm
Too bad we closed all the long-term psych hospitals years and years ago, huh?
April 2, 2008 at 8:10 pm
Good thing you restrained your self, a husband like that WOULD have filed a complaint. What a loser. And I say that if the stuffed shirts form on high DO try to tell you not to press charges, ignore them. Oh and they will tell you this on a friday. At about 4:45pm. right before they run out the door.
April 2, 2008 at 8:54 pm
so which martial arts gym do you go to??
I was going to be a wise guy and say “The School of Hard Knocks,” but that would be way too corny.
Actually we just have a small local gym that we go to - not one of the national chains.
April 2, 2008 at 9:06 pm
Ok seriously. You should have kept her from punching her? And it was ok for her to do so because you managed to avoid injury? And this is a grown woman? Yeesh.
April 3, 2008 at 2:32 am
I think I would have placed the gastric tube myself after that.
I did.
April 3, 2008 at 2:57 pm
The husband is probably on the receiving end of her violence on a regular basis, so she will probably hit him for you.
Anyone who gives you grief over this obviously does not understand the problems of restraining a violent patient while trying to keep everyone from being injured. Even joint locks are sometimes ineffective. I have had to release my grip to get a better grip, because it felt as if the joint would dislocate or the bone would break if I maintained my grip.
Maybe next shift someone will bring you some cookies.
April 3, 2008 at 4:31 pm
“She’s a psych patient anyway. She didn’t know what she was doing.”
Does this mean the husband was preparing the way for a dismissal of the charges?
That’s the impression I got from all the questions and the way he was asking them. Almost as if he had been through it before and knew what defenses to raise.
April 3, 2008 at 5:25 pm
Wow. Beaten by a woman . While you want to ruing someones life with criminal charges for taking a swing? - And then you wonder why you have such a litigous society. It is because of crap like this! If somebody takes a swing at you - hit them back. Sadly for you americans the only answer is “go to court” - and then you whine and bitch about how you can get sued.
You’re sounding like the patient’s husband. Using your logic, then you seem to think that it would be OK if I smacked you in the face a couple of times because I didn’t like your comment. After all, you could always hit me back. Hey, we should have a society where it’s OK to just beat the crap out of people whenever we want. Just like Great Britain.
April 3, 2008 at 7:56 pm
It’s situations like this that makes me so bloody mad that my state doesn’t have a law about assault on health care workers. Good on you though for pressing charges. People need to learn that it isn’t OK to assault someone trying to help you.
Even if you got your butt kicked by a girl….
April 4, 2008 at 1:49 am
#9 Max?
So what if she had been swinging on some 98 pound doc or nurse? She obviously didn’t hesitate to swing on him, what if it had been some little chick that she really could have beaten the shit out of? Not only that, but she did catch him by his eye, what if she’d actually done some damage to his eye? Ruin her life? Sounds to me like the quality of her life is shit already, maybe if she’s locked up awhile they can get her on meds to straighten her out.
April 5, 2008 at 5:16 am
You did the right thing in pressing charges. I was glad, as I read down through, to see that you did.
April 6, 2008 at 5:35 pm
Maybe the husband was right? She was suicidal when she came in, and could reasonably be assumed to be a danger to herself and others. . Restraints were a good idea, especially considering her early combativeness.
April 6, 2008 at 10:43 pm
I know exactly what you mean. This is a country of wisenheimers. Everyone is poking their proboscii into everyone else’s business.
We have a saying:
No one fornicates in the street because eventually someone will come along and say, “That’s not how it’s done!”
April 8, 2008 at 9:20 am
At my hospital, we’d tease the crap outta you for the remainder of the shift and then buy you a beer and a couple of shots after work. There’s a somewhat posh bar right by the hospital that opens at 7 am just for this purpose. We’d, of course, call ahead and make a reservation under the last name “Pants”, first name “Sissy”.
Don’t worry - I’m getting harassed all over the place.
I already got a “memo” about JCAHO requirements for staff safety.
April 8, 2008 at 10:22 pm
Guess by the time you were imagining what you COULD do to her you were pretty pissed. Don’t blame you. Glad no one got hurt.
Enjoyed the post.
Oh and that was a scene worthy of E.R. or if you were J.D. on Scrubs, we would have been able to see all the things you were imagining.
May 13, 2008 at 5:28 am
As I was sewing up her kid’s laceration, I had a mother tell me the story of her own laceration getting sewn when she was the age her child is now. She told me that when she got the lidocaine to numb her up, she started to scream and that her mother (current patient’s GM) punched the doctor. We had been having a nice conversation before that, but after that comment, I looked her right in the face and told her that had I been her doctor, her mother would have spent the night (and possibly longer) in jail. She said, “Well, you know, you have to understand parents and their kids. . .” I replied, “Doctors do things to help you/your kid that you chose not to learn to do, train for 7-15 years after college, work entire 12-hour shifts without eating or using the bathroom. . .and you want to punch me?” I wish somebody would. You will not pass go, you will not collect $200. You will go directly to jail.